If the old Expanded Universe is coming to an end, it doesnt seem like such a radical change to hand everything over to a publisher who hasnt worked on the franchise in decades. The Original Trilogy Era - dealing with the Rebellion and the fall of the Empire. According to StarWars.com, Demand for past tales of the Expanded Universe will keep them in print, presented under the new Legends banner., Gavia Baker-Whitelaw is a staff writer at the Daily Dot, covering geek culture and fandom. Problem is they never mention Thrawn or Ashoka or Grogu in the sequels. Are the rumors surrounding the Star Wars Sequels being decanonized true? Disney has brought in a lot of new fans who want to see more, and on top of the people who aren't obsessed with Kathleen Kennedy conspiracy theories or still seething over a trilogy that they didn't like, there will be plenty of folks who are interested in post-sequel content. Awful." the mandalorian saga, to date, has been set approximately five years after episode vi: return of the jedi (1983), obi-wan kenobi (starring ewan mcgregor as the jedi master and hayden christensen as. They are based around the three main trilogies of the so-called Skywalker Saga: The Prequel Era - dealing with the fall of the Old Republic and the Jedi. Plus, theres the fact that even mostStar Warsfans havent consumed every aspect of the Expanded Universe, never mind the people who are working on the new movies. We demand that Kathleen Kennedy be removed as President of Lucasfilm effective immediately. Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh. TRoS made less than half of what TFA did. TFA establishes that all of Luke's students died? But they're not going to retcon things like "Luke failed at building a new Jedi Academy and went to live in seclusion," because that's kind of a major plot point in the sequels. Well it seems like the sequels . Will you do the same? The storylines are terrible. The Star Wars sequel trilogy The Force Awakens (2015), The Last Jedi (2017), and The Rise of Skywalker (2019) left a sour taste in the mouths of millions of fans. On the other hand, decanonizing a series of films that would put a damper on the prospects of future installments would be beneficial to the studio and the legacy of the franchise as a whole, as it could sincerely restore the interest among most long-time fans of. I encourage them to officially relegate episode 7-9 to same place they've relegated Shadows of the Empire, Splinter of the Mind's Eye, and The Ewok Adventure. The sequel trilogy is a film trilogy in the Star Wars franchise, sequel to the original trilogy. Star Wars: The Force Unleashed was an action-adventure title that hit store shelves in 2008 and gave players control over massive Force powers. Oh, definitely. Published Feb 23, 2021. Disney certainly has the legal right to make these films, but they don't have the power to say they're canonical. Many Star Wars fans are not particularly happy about the new movies, and some feel that Disney threw out the baby with the bathwater when it came to the expanded universe. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The charming game had terrific level design and gameplay and spawned an arcade version and a sequel. Willmark Well-Known Member Apr 8, 2021 #43 This is how Luke should be remembered not whatever Episode VIII was. In order to give maximum creative freedom to the filmmakers and also preserve an element of surprise and discovery for the audience,Star WarsEpisodes VII-IX will not tell the same story told in the post-Return of the JediExpanded Universe. Almost every single TV show, book, comic, game and ride that Disney has made connects to the sequels in one way or another. By a fluke of the calendar, this week marks . Why would Lucas Film do this? Star Wars-related attractions in Disney World and Disneyland are heavily influenced by the characters and settings of the sequels, and it's doubtful that the mind-bogglingly expensive. They'll draw on characters and concepts from Legends, try to work around what the sequels established, ignore the ST era for awhile, and pander to the fans like you've never been pandered to before. Lucas Film is strongly considering removing the sequel trilogy from Star Wars Canon and making it part of Star Wars Legends. As of now, the official Star Wars canon consists of the six existing movies and the recent Clone Wars TV series. TRoS didn't even bother to explain Palpatine's resurrection? "These stories are the immovable objects of Star Wars history, the. NEW LAUNCH : LIMITED EDITION BATMAN COLLECTIBLE. The choice to detach the Expanded Universe from the new movies was a practical one, and it leaves room to make sure all future spin-offsdoalign with official canon. 2. Although this topic may sound like one you would ponder about while taking a shower, there is still some compelling discussion to be made about it. Star Wars is an American epic space opera franchise, created by George Lucas and centered around a film series that began with the eponymous 1977 movie. Follow her on Twitter: @Hello_Tailor, Sounds like how he rewrote Tesla: TikToker jokes that Elon Musk wanted Twitter TV series to include him. In the case of the Star Wars sequel trilogy, it is fairly evident that the reception towards the films was largely negative. Only idiots would think that the sequels would be decanonized lol. One of the biggest topics of speculation in the run-up to the newStar Warsmovie is how it will fit in with the preexisting Expanded Universe. According to the Disney canon, they shouldn't be. In the case of the, sequel trilogy, it is fairly evident that the reception towards the films was largely negative. With Sony, how often did spiderman get redone? Disney had no issue decanonizing a lot of work when they bought LucasFilms, once they realize the sequels are not the money cow the OT, TCW, and PT are I'm not sure it would be shocking for them to redo them. Following the Walt Disney Company's October 30, 2012 acquisition of Lucasfilm Ltd. from George Lucas, Disney announced Star Wars: The Force Awakens for a 2015 release, with two follow-ups, Star Wars: The Last Jedi and Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker released in 2017 and 2019, respectively. Season seven included the introduction of The Bad Batch, as well as an. Are the sequels being Decanonized? Now, there is a point to be made regarding the fact that big Hollywood studios simply cannot decanonize films as and when they please. This guys was badass all for 30 seconds . Answer: Two things: First of all: It's not "time you'll never have back", it's time you never had in the first place, it's like saying I feel pain because I'll never be able to watch Andy Kaufman shows live again (the guy died 17 years before I was born, never saw him in the first place). A look at each Star Wars trilogy, the original saga, the Prequel trilogy and Disney's sequel trilogy, emphasizing global box office and rate of return. Star Wars has undergone a lot of changes since the property was acquired by Disney in 2012. Unpopular opinion: Zil - Eth bridge will not have such a i just realized something. Yet it only succeeds because it is a Star Wars film. This petition starter stood up and took action. That being said, there is also an argument to be made as to why studios should be allowed to decanonize films when the situation beckons for such a decision to be made. Please sign this petition to show The Walt Disney Company that they have gravely underestimated the level of loyalty and power of True Fans of George Lucas's original Star Wars, and that we won't accept their so-called "Sequel Trilogy" as canon of Star Wars. Andor episode 10 asks: How does someone become a Rebel leader? No baby Yodas, no Mandalorian or Kenobi television series can make us accept the betrayal and disrespect that Disney has treated George Lucas, Mark Hamill, Anthony Daniels, Timothy M. Rose and us, the Fans who have made Star Wars a multi billion dollar movie franchise over four decades,with in the past your years. Lucas had planned a sequel trilogy as early as 1976, but canceled it by 1981. The Star Wars sequel trilogy proved to be a bit of . Creators of newStar Warsentertainment have full access to the rich content of the Expanded Universe. After . But I never will think that Disney would decanonize the trilogy. Specializing in sci-fi movies and superheroes, she also appears as a film and TV critic on BBC radio. This is not to say that prior. Which droid would you take to infiltrate the Death Star How long did Padme have to pause between these two lines? This may sound like a pretty brutal decision, but it was unavoidable. What's more, it was backed-up by taking over $2 billion at the worldwide box office, breaking records in the process.At that point, Star Wars: The Last Jedi was already in development, with a release date of May 26, 2017 penciled in. After all, these production houses have invested millions upon millions of dollars to make these movies and market them to the public. or do people seriously expect it to happen? All they could do is give those crybabies some fanservice so they hopefully stop whining about the sequels, because the end result has to be the same. It was a contingency plan that was up and running. It is certainly a tricky question to answer and a costly one at that. The editor of 1977's original "Star Wars" film executed order 66 at those responsible for episodes VII through IX, flat out saying "It sucks. I really dislike TLJ but there is no way theyre going to decanonize it. And so on and so on. Depending on which side of the aisle you are on, you would either scoff or cheer at the prospect of seeing the sequel trilogy suddenly evaporate out of existence (not literally, of course), and we are not here to say who is right and who is wrong in the argument. It could potentially make the studio appear humble in audiences eyes, as the studios action could be perceived as a willingness to admit their mistake and subsequently make reparations. After all, LucasFilm was never going to make a big-screen adaptation of a series of tie-in novels published in the 1980s. 3501, Jack Northrop Ave, Suite #EU514, Hawthorne, CA, 90250, USA, 4, Jalan Usahawan 6, Setapak Jaya, 53300, Kuala Lumpur, MY, Now, there is a point to be made regarding the fact that big. Originally airing from 2008-2014, Disney revived the series, with the finale taking place on Star Wars Day, May 4, 2020. Elsewhere, she co-hosts the pop culture podcast Overinvested. The real money maker is merchandise. He also provided Disney with an outline for a sequel . On the one hand, keeping the sequel trilogy in canon will remove the risk of alienating the fans that genuinely enjoyed the films and prevent the need to fork out more money to produce a more accepted version of the movies. It would be akin to filmmaking suicide for the studio to suddenly deem a series of films that were once canon to abruptly be disassociated with the main franchise. Rather than being some kind of epic disaster for old-school fans, this is basically what the big-name superhero comics have been doing for years: hitting the reset button to make way for new stories. The Clone Wars (2008) The Clone Wars (2008 cartoon) is part of both continuities, though it creates lots of problems in Legends and shouldn't have been part of it. Here are the top 10 unused Star Wars sequel trilogy ideas. Also according to the Disney canon, Palpatine had clones ready to go on Exogal. What are retcons? Retcon that he trained Grogu, Leia and others before formally establishing his ill-fated academy. It would also decanonize all books and other expanded material post RotJ to give the galaxy a completely clean. I swe. People got mad over the prequels, too -- and before that they got mad over Ewoks and the Holiday Special. Mandalorian got a ton of my older family members in their 40s and fifties, men and women, into Star Wars when they didn't really care before, and now they're excited to see anything Star Wars. For example, elements of the EU are included in [upcoming animated series]Star Wars Rebels.. Lucasfilm released the "special edition" versions of the original three, which were a mixed bag, but they came with the. Fans getting mad means nothing towards canon. It fails as a sequel to the original trilogies. They already are. While the sequel was not received as well, both titles became infamous among Star Wars fans. English isnt my first language. This petition starter stood up and took action. You have to remember, the sequels ignored a hell of a lot of Star Wars lore that is considered canon. It's merely a dumbed down, poorly written and directed rip-off of the Original Star Wars Trilogy, that's disrespected and destroyed everything we hold dear in Star Wars. This also helps to make sense of the recent move to give allStar Warscomics rights back to Marvel, when for the past 30-odd years theyd been published by DarkHorse Comics. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google. Thank You Very Much for supporting this cause! How many have ties to the sequel trilogy? Until our demands are met, we will continue to protest and boycott everything Disney Star Wars, starting with the upcoming Star Wars Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker. (An in-depth look) Discovery Park Studios Jul 1, 2020 Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next Screamface Well-Known Member Apr 10, 2021 #61 The Last Jedi is bad. The plan is to do a lot more than Mando. Each season, presumably, would rework the events of one of the sequel trilogy movies, Star Wars: Episode VII - The Force Awakens (2015), Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi (2017),. Virtually everyone currently working as a writer or artist in theStar Warstie-in franchise will have some kind of background in reading that now-defunct canon of stories, and plenty of those books and comics are beloved by generations of fans. .more Share. 12/4/2018. The films production and marketing each cost $400-500 million. Disney made half of what they bought Star Wars for with their first movie, and another 2 billion with the other 2 trilogy movies. Star Wars: The Last . The details of how they'll pull this off story-wise are available on youtube, just google "Star Wars sequel removed from canon" and choose from the many videos available. This isnt an unpopular opinion. That being said, there is also an argument to be made as to why studios should be allowed to decanonize films when the situation beckons for such a decision to be made. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Check out our other related articles, or pick up one of our expertly crafted Star Wars pewter figurines now. Clone Wars (2003 microseries) was Genndy Tartakovsky and is only part of Legends (though most of the series has been recanonized since . It could very well sow the seeds of distrust among its diehard followers, regardless of whether the fandom enjoyed the films or not. Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published. This decision will settle a lot of ongoing arguments about what is and isnt real canon, but LucasFilm is evidently trying to make it as clear as possible that it still values the Expanded Universe. The Star Wars sequel trilogy. Answer (1 of 103): At the risk of sounding like a whiny ungrateful nerd Because it ruined Star Wars. The Sequel Trilogy's production design was amazing when it wasn't outright copying the Original Trilogy, giving fans some great new ship designs and capturing the gritty feel of old-school Star Wars. Unpopular opinion: Typhlosion's 3D model is fine. The Star Wars sequel trilogy is something all fans feel strongly about, but a lot of people want the sequels to be retconned. It became one of the fastest-selling Star Wars based video games and a sequel was made soon after. . 19,859 views Jul 5, 2020 Discussing the rumors of Disney DECANONIZING Star Wars Episodes 7-9, the SEQUEL TRILOGY Rumors and how it makes no sense but what they COULD do. It would be akin to filmmaking suicide for the studio to suddenly deem a series of films that were once canon to abruptly be disassociated with the main franchise. The Star Wars Legends distinction. I encourage everyone who agrees with this sentiment to sign this petition to have Episodes 7-9 decanonized so that perhaps one day this story can be told in an authentic way one day in the future, if they need to be told at all. . Although this topic may sound like one you would ponder about while taking a shower, there is still some compelling discussion to be made about it. The sequels also wouldn't be placed under Legends because they're two different continuities that don't fit together. Its disney were not having a wipe like the 1st time ever again. At least in my lifetime ive accepted this unfortanatly im only 27. Why do people still think this is a thing that could happen? They were a financial success for them and it would be a huge slap in the face to everyone from the actors and directors to set designers and make up artists. studios simply cannot decanonize films as and when they please. As the announcement post explained: Now, with an exciting future filled with new cinematic installments ofStar Wars, all aspects ofStar Warsstorytelling moving forward will be connected. But to claim that Disneythe single-most successful film studio in Hollywood historyis going to erase the sequel trilogy is pure lunacy. Mainline saga movies to be on par with Avengers movies. Depending on which side of the aisle you are on, you would either scoff or cheer at the prospect of seeing the sequel trilogy suddenly evaporate out of existence (not literally, of course), and we are not here to say who is right and who is wrong in the argument. As of now, the officialStar Warscanon consists of the six existing movies and the recentClone WarsTV series. Decanonizing the sequels is so disrespectful to everyone who worked on them. ), referred to as the expanded universe, or EU. What was your first reaction when you watch this scene? Lucasfilm has justissued a statementsaying that the entire Expanded Universe is no longer official canon. We demand that Star Wars Episodes VII-VIII-IX be decanonized from the official Star Wars (Skywalker) Saga and Disney make the true third trilogy based on original story treatments by the creator of Star Wars, George Lucas. I'm not saying they will, but Disney bought Star Wars to be MCU level success. Posted on Apr 26, 2014Updated on May 31, 2021, 10:09 am CDT. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. (edited by 701847) Look at the upcoming slate of Star Wars projects. Disney Rushed Out The Star Wars Sequels. to return and continue to support the franchise that they are so very passionate about. They can't get rid of them without affecting everything else and they've sunk too much money and time into this iteration of Star Wars to fully reboot it again. Why the Star Wars sequels are good? Therefore, the sensible thing for the studio to do would be to swallow their pride and write off the said trilogy, allowing it to remain as an experiment gone wrong rather than let it stew in a broth of frustration and rejection that will eventually spill out into future projects and sour their potential. These stories are the immovable objects ofStar Warshistory, the characters and events to which all other tales must align,explainedthe announcement on StarWars.com. It's pretty much a fact, isn't it? But the Planes movies are not pure products of Pixar Animation Studios. _____________________________________________________________________________________________________. Until recently the Expanded Universe fleshed out hundreds of sequels to the original trilogy and beyond, but the arrival ofEpisodes VIItoIXinevitably puts a stop to that. It's not unpopular. No, I'm not talking about the female lead. They quickly greenlit a new trilogy of films, started planning multiple spin-off films, and recently . Unless all three get killed off I think Jon and Dave are ignoring the sequels going forward. How many iterations of the Hulk did we get? Every story needs a fr. LucasFilm also released aYouTubevideo celebrating the Expanded Universe, with messages from variousStar Warswriters, artists, and video game concept designers. The idea to erase The Force Awakens and its sequels from the current Star. Show an Imperial remnant experimenting with cloning and Force sensitive individuals. Baby Yoda, and brining in Asoka open up a giant can of worms when it comes to Jedi and force users. Like The Last Jedi is my least favourite Star Wars film to the point that I haven't seen The Rise Of Skywalker yet. But the movies themselves, the stories they tell and the fates of the OT heroes are set in stone. I can't believe the sequels, set in a large universe with a limitless number of characters, didn't mention the character of Grogu. It fails as a sequel to TFA. The trilogy consists of episodes VII through IX, chronologically following the prequel trilogy ( Episodes I - III; 1999-2005) and the original trilogy ( Episodes IV - VI; 1977-1983), serving as the final act of the "Skywalker saga". Now that The Mandalorian has reunited the fanbase and become a cultural phenomenon, a lot of people have been expressing a hope that Disney will decanonize the sequel trilogy and let Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni construct a new post-RotJ continuity. if disney smelled a bigger fiancial success they would do it in a heart beat, The actors and directors are already displeased with Disney because of the sequels and how they turned out. Therefore, the sensible thing for the studio to do would be to swallow their pride and write off the said trilogy, allowing it to remain as an experiment gone wrong rather than let it stew in a broth of frustration and rejection that will eventually spill out into future projects and sour their potential. But that is never going to happen. Because the internet is the internet,. Want more Star Wars content? All figures cast from high quality pewter. Disney, Abrams and many of the fans, it seems, want the same thing: a safe, predictable, intensely curated Star Wars canon, where every film, book, comic and game comes tightly scripted and . Regardless of your opinion of the movies themselves, it's an undisputed fact that the sequel trilogy divided the fanbase and failed to meet Disney's financial expectations. While the universe that readers knew is changing, it is not being discarded. And if anyone knows how to build an extended universe of interlocking storylines, its Marvel. Yes, because they are their places in the chronologic universe formed by the movies of the Disney Animated Canon. Spanning decades of novels, comics, video games, and more, the Expanded Universe is now too vast and complex to tie into a new trilogy of movies that will have to be accessible to new viewers. Podracers are a terrifically unique type of vehicle and a very Star Wars concept . May the Force Be With George Lucas and his True Star Wars! Theyve made their money back on the films but not as much as youd think. Episodes 7-9 would be removed from canon and only movies 1-6 would count once again. Now that The Mandalorian has reunited the fanbase and become a cultural phenomenon, a lot of people have been expressing a hope that Disney will decanonize the sequel trilogy and let Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni construct a new post-RotJ continuity. What they can - and will - do is work around them. After all, these production houses have invested millions upon millions of dollars to make these movies and market them to the public. And Lucasfilm is still referencing the sequels just fine. I have no idea how people still believe this is a thing thats going to happen. Only if they get their Star Wars "news" from people making up shit on YouTube. It defies financial logic and ignores the company's . It could very well sow the seeds of distrust among its diehard followers, regardless of whether the fandom enjoyed the films or not. So many of the movies' most striking shots were made possible because of Lucasfilm's amazing production design team. The Prequel Trilogy Then, in the mid-90s, the universe stirred again. When Star Wars: The Force Awakens released in 2015, it was a huge statement that Star Wars was back. It is certainly a tricky question to answer and a costly one at that. trilogies had not faced any negative criticism in the past, but there is a distinct difference between disliking a film and loathing it, of which the sequel trilogy is undoubtedly in the latter category. The Star Wars Sequel Trilogy concluded over a year ago, however many fans still clamor for The Force Awakens, The Last Jedi, and The Rise of Skywalker to be . On the other hand, decanonizing a series of films that would put a damper on the prospects of future installments would be beneficial to the studio and the legacy of the franchise as a whole, as it could sincerely restore the interest among most long-time fans of Star Wars to return and continue to support the franchise that they are so very passionate about. Regardless of your opinion of the movies themselves, it's an undisputed fact that the sequel trilogy divided the fanbase and failed to meet Disney's financial expectations. Newsletter: Inside the Fat Bear Week scandal, Ive been to multiple Wingstops, they try to act like they dont got it: Customer shares hack to getting $5 meal for Wingstop, *First Published: Apr 26, 2014, 1:52 pm CDT. They did not spend 4.5 billion dollars to purchase LucasFilm intending to launch a stand along sequel trilogy, and so far they haven't done anything with it since it was released. The Sequel Trilogy Era dealing with the First Order/Resistance . The latest trilogy in the revered Star Wars saga has come to an end, and critics and fans largelt agree that the final product is an absolute betrayal to the the themes, characters, and vision that made the pre-Disney films so culturally important. On the one hand, keeping the sequel trilogy in canon will remove the risk of alienating the fans that genuinely enjoyed the films and prevent the need to fork out more money to produce a more accepted version of the movies. The Star Wars Legends distinction. Whether or not they will or should is up for debate, but Disney and Lucasfilm have a way to retcon the Star Wars sequels. They wont publicly decanonize but they might retcon them. Will you do the same? If they think the best way to getting Avengers level of revenue out of the Star Wars Universe is to ignore the sequels, they absolutely will. All Star Wars is divided into three parts. 3. I encourage them to officially relegate episode 7-9 to same place they've relegated Shadows of the Empire, Splinter of the Mind's Eye, and The Ewok Adventure. If Any Place Should Have Aliens its This Yet There is None, Press J to jump to the feed. It could potentially make the studio appear humble in audiences eyes, as the studios action could be perceived as a willingness to admit their mistake and subsequently make reparations. As for the older fans who are worried that their favorite books and comics will no longer be available, fear not. This is not to say that prior Star Wars trilogies had not faced any negative criticism in the past, but there is a distinct difference between disliking a film and loathing it, of which the sequel trilogy is undoubtedly in the latter category. Instead, we simply want to consider the possibility of this topic coming to pass. The rumor stated that Disney would render the events in the sequel trilogy null and void through the Veil of the Force, introduced in Star Wars Rebels. But they won't commit to a full reboot. 4/10 Episode 1: Racer (1999) Coinciding with the release of The Phantom Menace in 1999, Episode 1: Racer put players in the seat of a podracer as seen in that film. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Star Wars fans have never had a problem with strong female characters: And I'm also not talking about the abandoning of the EU. If anything, The Mando is already contradicting the sequels universe. They may have turned a profit, but they still underperformed.